Creative strategy
UGC that doesn’t look like an ad: 5 formats and how to brief creators
Most UGC fails because it looks like a script being read. Five formats that feel native to the feed, and how to brief creators so you get them.
Jonah Whitfield
Direct Response Copywriter
·2 min read
User-generated content works because it looks like something a real person posted. The problem is that a lot of “UGC ads” now look exactly like ads: the same ring light, the same excited voice, the same “OMG you guys.” People have learned to spot them and scroll past.
The fix isn’t better creators. It’s better formats and better briefs.
1. The honest review
A creator talks through what they liked, and one thing they didn’t. That small criticism is what makes the rest believable. Let them say it.
Opening line
“I’ve used this for a month. Two things I love, one thing I don’t.”
2. Problem, then fix
Show the annoying problem first, in real life, without the product. Then show the product solving it. The problem section is what makes viewers think “that’s me.”
Opening line
“Every morning I [annoying problem]. This is what finally fixed it.”
3. Things I wish I’d known
Tips about using the product, framed as advice. It teaches people how to get value from it, and it feels like helpful content rather than selling.
Opening line
“Three things I wish I’d known before buying [product].”
4. The first try
The creator unboxes and uses the product for the first time, on camera, with real reactions. It only works if it’s genuinely the first time, so send the product and ask them to film before they open it.
Opening line
“Everyone keeps telling me to try this. Let’s see.”
5. Side by side
The product next to what the viewer uses now: the old way versus the new way, or a cheaper alternative versus yours. Keep it fair, and compare against a type of product rather than a named competitor.
Opening line
“I tested this against the one I’ve used for years.”
How to brief creators
A UGC brief should give creators the points to hit, not the words to say. Scripts read word for word are one of the main reasons UGC sounds fake.
- Give talking points, not lines. Three or four things to mention, in their own words.
- Ask for several hooks. Three different openings for the same video costs them minutes and gives you three ads.
- Ask for raw footage too. Unedited clips let your editor cut new versions later.
- Set the basics. Vertical 9:16, natural light, clear audio, product visible in the first seconds, no music you don’t have rights to.
- Share two or three reference ads with a note on what to take from each.
UGC brief, short version
Format: [one of the five above]
Talking points: [3–4 points]
Must show: [product moment that matters]
Avoid: [claims, words, competitors]
Deliver: 1 main video, 3 alternative hooks, raw clips
Get usage rights in writing
Before you pay, agree on how you can use the content: for how long, on which channels, whether you can run it as a paid ad, and whether you can run it from the creator’s own account through Meta’s partnership ads. Each of these usually changes the price. Write it down, even for small deals.
Written by
Jonah Whitfield · Direct Response Copywriter
Jonah writes hooks, scripts and landing pages, and keeps a very large swipe file.
Keep the ads that inspire you
Swoopface saves ads from the Meta Ad Library, with their video, copy and landing page, into boards you can share with your team.