Blog

Creative strategy

Following the wrong brands can sink your business. Here’s how to pick the right ones

Copying a brand with different economics leads you to offers, budgets and ads you can’t afford. A short guide to choosing role models that match your numbers.

Daniel Okafor

Creative Strategist

·3 min read

Most marketers pick brands to follow the same way: whoever has the most impressive ads. That’s usually a large, well-funded company with a team of dozens and a budget to match. Their ads are great. Their ads are also built for a business that looks nothing like yours.

Inspiration isn’t free. Every brand you study quietly teaches you what “normal” looks like: how big a discount is, how polished a video should be, how long you should wait for results. If you learn “normal” from a brand with very different numbers, you’ll make decisions that make sense for them and hurt you.

Five ways the wrong role model costs you

  1. Offers you can’t afford. A brand with high margins and strong repeat purchases can lose money on a 40% first-order discount and earn it back later. If your customers buy once, that same offer just loses money.
  2. Budgets that don’t scale down. Some ad strategies only work with a lot of spend: broad awareness campaigns, many creators at once, constant testing. At a small budget they never collect enough data to tell you anything.
  3. Patience you don’t have. Brand-building ads pay off over months or years. That’s a fine bet for a company with funding. It’s a dangerous one if you need this month’s ads to pay this month’s bills.
  4. Production you can’t match. Chasing a studio look with a small budget usually produces something that looks expensive and generic at the same time.
  5. Customers who aren’t yours. A $300 product is a considered purchase. A $25 product is often an impulse buy. They need completely different ads.
High-margin impulseStrong hooks, bold visualsConsidered premiumStory, proof, educationVolume gameBundles, offers, speedPricey, thin marginRetention or it doesn’t workPRICE POINT →GROSS MARGIN →YouThe brand you copy
If the brand you study sits in a different box, its playbook probably won’t transfer.

A quick example

Picture a small candle brand selling $28 candles. The founder admires a large home-fragrance brand that runs beautiful, slow brand films and a permanent “buy two, get one free” offer. So the founder makes a slow brand film and launches the same offer.

The film looks lovely and sells almost nothing, because a $28 candle is an impulse buy and the film takes 20 seconds to show the product. The offer brings in orders, but after shipping, packaging and ad costs, each one loses money. Nothing about the ads was bad. They were just copied from the wrong business.

Borrow ideas from anyone. Borrow strategy only from brands whose numbers look like yours.

How to choose brands worth following

Keep a short list of “strategy” role models, brands similar enough that their choices tell you something about yours. Check each one against these questions:

QuestionGood sign
Is their price close to yours?Within roughly half to double your average order
Do customers buy as often as yours?Similar repeat cycle: one-off, monthly, yearly
Are they at a similar stage?Founder-led or small team, not a household name
Is their ad volume realistic for you?You could make a similar number of ads per month
Is the purchase similar?Same mix of impulse and consideration

You’ll often find the best role models are slightly bigger brands in a different category with similar economics. A $40 skincare brand can learn more from a $40 coffee subscription than from a $200 luxury serum.

What to take from brands that aren’t like you

This doesn’t mean ignoring the giants. It means borrowing different things from them. From large brands, take craft: editing rhythm, typography, how they write a headline, how they show a product in hand. Those transfer at any budget. Leave behind the parts that depend on their money: the offer, the media plan, the timeline.

The short version

  • Impressive ads can still be a bad model for your business.
  • Match role models on price, repeat rate, stage and budget before you copy their strategy.
  • Take craft from anyone. Take offers and media plans only from brands like you.

Written by

Daniel Okafor · Creative Strategist

Daniel spends most of his week in the Ad Library, taking apart what brands run and why it works.

Keep the ads that inspire you

Swoopface saves ads from the Meta Ad Library, with their video, copy and landing page, into boards you can share with your team.